In Roof trial, gift of gun went unblocked
CHARLESTON – In the middle of April 2015, Dylann Roof browsed a case filled with Glock pistols at a South Carolina gun store, spoke to a clerk and filled out required federal paperwork for a purchase.
Three days later, after waiting for a background check, Roof returned to Shooter’s Choice, to purchase the .45 caliber handgun. But after walking out, he returned only moments later “cash in hand,” the general manager of the shop, Ronald Thrailkill, testified Monday morning.
The Glock Roof was purchasing came packaged with three magazines. He decided to buy two more.
Roof had turned 21 a little more than a week earlier, when his father gave him a card picturing an otter, in it a handwritten note, promising his son cash for a gun, partly congratulations for his new job.
“I.O.U. Good for up to $400 toward pistol & CWP [concealed weapons permit]. I love you!” Franklin Bennett Roof wrote.
Two months after that trip to Shooter’s Choice, nine black parishioners of Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church were shot to death during a Wednesday night Bible study using the handgun Roof purchased. Investigators have testified he shot more than 70 hollow point bullets in the church’s fellowship hall, many of them at people trying to hide under folding tables draped with white cloths.
Jurors on Monday began hearing a fourth day of testimony against Roof, an admitted white supremacist facing 33 federal charges, some relating to hate crimes and obstruction of religion in the deadly attack.
The government’s case might conclude Wednesday, prosecutors have said. Roof’s defense team is expected to offer few, if any witnesses, meaning the jury will likely begin deliberating this week.
Three days after completing the federal firearm application, personnel at Shooter’s Choice had not heard if the sale to Roof was approved or denied by the National Instant Criminal Background Check System, an arm of the FBI that determines if a purchaser can be denied for past felonies, drug use, mental health issues or related concerns, Thrailkill said.
Without a formal denial from federal officials, firearms dealers can legally complete sales to customers after the three-day waiting period expires. Roof received the weapon, Thrailkill testified, and soon after purchased three more magazines, each capable of holding 13 rounds.
Roof, however, with a felony drug charge on his record from March 2015, should never have been allowed to purchase the weapon, FBI Director James Comey said a month after the attack at Mother Emanuel.
He called that error “a mistake, in a matter of heartbreaking importance to all of us,” one that he said was the result of confusion over geography.
Roof's March arrest on felony drug charges was mistakenly attributed to the Lexington County, South Carolina, Sheriff's Department, not Columbia police. The Lexington County Sheriff's Department operates the jail where Roof had been detained.
Had the examiner viewed the Columbia police report on Roof’s drug arrest, she would have found that Roof admitted to drug possession, which would have triggered an immediate denial by the FBI NICS review process, according to bureau guidelines.
Because of the confusion over the agencies involved, Roof was allowed to purchase the Glock without incident.
However, in a first for Thrailkill, the Shooter’s Choice manager testified he received a phone call from a NICS investigator on June 29, 2015.
That call came more than two months after Roof’s gun purchase. He was told to deny the purchase.
The notification came 12 days after the Mother Emanuel shootings. As is typical of a NICS denial of a gun purchase, Thrailkill said he was not told a reason.
